Is Your Pool's Auto-Fill Hiding a Leak?
An auto-fill can't tell evaporation from a leak. How to switch it off and run the bucket test, and what the pump on/off comparison tells you.
An automatic pool top-up valve is convenient. It keeps the water at the skimmer, protects the pump from running dry, and saves you dragging the hose around every few days.
It also has a downside nobody mentions when it's installed: it hides leaks. A pool that is losing far more water than evaporation can look perfectly full, while the extra water is quietly added from the mains and shows up only on your water bill.
How an Auto-Fill Masks a Leak
An auto-fill valve works like a toilet cistern float. When the level drops below a set point, it opens and lets in mains water until the level is back up.
It can't tell evaporation from a leak. Whether the pool loses 4 mm a day to the sun and wind or 20 mm a day through a cracked pipe, the valve simply tops it up. The pool always looks normal.
The only signs are indirect:
- A higher water bill that can't be explained by the house or garden
- The meter turning when nobody is using water and the irrigation is off
- The auto-fill running often, which you may hear as a hiss of water in the fill line
- Damp ground, sunken paving or cracks near the pool or the pump area
- Chemical balance that keeps drifting, because fresh water is constantly diluting the pool
How to Test for a Hidden Leak
Step 1: Switch off the auto-fill
Close the valve on the auto-fill's supply line. Without this, every test below is meaningless.
Step 2: Do the bucket test
- Fill a bucket with pool water and stand it on the top step, so it is at the same temperature and exposed to the same sun and wind as the pool.
- Mark the water level inside the bucket, and mark the pool's level on the skimmer or tile.
- Leave both for 24 to 48 hours with the pump on its normal schedule.
- Compare. The bucket shows what evaporation alone took. If the pool has dropped clearly more than the bucket, the difference is a leak.
Step 3: Repeat with the pump off
Do the same test with the pump switched off.
- More loss with the pump on points to the return side of the plumbing, which is under pressure when the pump runs.
- More loss with the pump off points to the suction lines or main drain.
- The same loss either way points to the shell or a fitting, such as a skimmer, light or inlet.
What a Hidden Leak Can Cost
Pool leaks add up quickly because the loss is spread over the whole surface of the pool. As an example, on a pool with 40 m² of water surface, every extra millimetre a day is 40 litres a day. A leak of 10 mm a day above evaporation is 400 litres a day, or about 12 kilolitres a month, and on most Gauteng tariffs that water is charged at your highest block rate, because it comes on top of your household use.
Water escaping from a pool for months can also wash out the ground under paving and around the pool shell, so the repair can grow the longer the leak runs.
Finding the Leak Without Draining the Pool
Professional pool leak detection works with the pool full:
- Dye testing around skimmers, lights, inlets, the main drain and any cracks shows exactly where water is being drawn out.
- Pressure testing each pipe line shows whether the plumbing holds pressure, and which line is losing it.
- Acoustic and tracer-gas equipment pinpoint a leaking pipe under the paving, so only a small section needs to be lifted.
Our pool leak detection service covers all of this, and our guide on evaporation versus a leak has more on what normal water loss looks like.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Should I remove the auto-fill altogether? A: No. It is useful, but switch it off for a few days every few months and check the level, and always switch it off before a leak test or inspection.
Q: How much water loss is normal? A: It depends on the weather. On hot, dry and windy summer days a pool can lose several millimetres a day to evaporation; in cool, still weather much less. The bucket test compares your pool against evaporation on the same days, which is more reliable than any rule of thumb.
Q: Can the auto-fill valve itself leak? A: Yes. A valve that doesn't close properly can overfill the pool, sending water out through the overflow or skimmer, and its supply line can leak underground like any other pipe.
Q: Do I need to drain the pool for a leak inspection? A: No. The pool needs to be full to mid-skimmer for the skimmer, inlets and pipework to be tested.
